Waterfront home in Sunset KeyFlorida Keys

Sunset Key is a private, 27-acre island about 500 yards off Key West, reached only by boat. It's one of the most exclusive addresses in the Keys, with fewer than 50 single-family homes, no cars and a 7-minute launch to Old Town. Over the past year the median sale price was about $6.6 million.

The Island Collective Realty is broker-led. Greg Gordon works directly with every Sunset Key buyer, with the discretion this market calls for.

Browse Sunset Key Homes

Sunset Key Real Estate

FLORIDA KEYS AREA GUIDE

Sunset Key gives you true island privacy without giving up Key West. The island is car-free and residential, with a white-sand beach and Gulf views, yet Old Town's restaurants and Mallory Square are a short boat ride away.

It's also part of the City of Key West, so you have city services and a Key West address. Buyers here are usually looking for a trophy second home that's easy to visit and easy to leave.

Why buyers choose Sunset Key

AREA OVERVIEW

Sunset Key waterfront home with private dock

What people love about Sunset Key

THE LIFESTYLE

A private white-sand beach faces the Gulf, and the island's name says the rest. Latitudes restaurant sits right on the water.

Beach and sunsets

A launch runs between Sunset Key and Key West about every 30 minutes from early morning to late evening.

Seven minutes to town

No cars

Sunset Key is reached only by boat, so the island is quiet, walkable and free of traffic.

Residential waterfront view in Sunset Key Florida Keys

Sunset Key is a small, luxury market of custom single-family homes, many with water views and pools. The median sale price was about $6.6 million over the past year, and only a few homes come up for sale each year.

The island was built in the 1960s by the U.S. Navy as Tank Island, then sold, cleared and renamed Sunset Key in 1994. Today it's privately held among its residents alongside the Sunset Key Cottages resort.all lifestyle fit when comparing opportunities here.

View Sunset Key Listings

Sunset Key homes and prices

HOMES AND PRICES

Private island ownership

Sunset Key appeals to buyers looking for a rare ownership opportunity in a secluded and highly desirable island setting.

What makes Sunset Key unique

THE AREA

Owners enjoy the benefit of being near Key West while returning to a quieter, more private island environment.

Access to Key West

Luxury home inventory

The market is known for upscale homes, curated surroundings, and a level of exclusivity that sets it apart from more traditional Florida Keys communities.

Life on Sunset Key is quiet and unhurried. Mornings are on the beach or the porch, lunch or dinner is at Latitudes, and when you want Key West, the launch drops you near Mallory Square in about seven minutes.

Getting here is easy. Key West International Airport is about 15 minutes from the launch, and owners park in Key West before crossing.

Life on Sunset Key

LIVING HERE

Sunset Key waterfront home with private dock

How do you get to Sunset Key?

By boat only. A launch runs about every 30 minutes between Key West, near Mallory Square, and Sunset Key, and the ride takes about seven minutes.

Sunset Key real estate FAQs

FAQS

Are cars allowed on Sunset Key?

No. Sunset Key is car-free, which keeps the island quiet and walkable.

What do homes cost on Sunset Key?

The median sale price was about $6.6 million over the past year, and only a few homes sell each year.

How many homes are on Sunset Key?

Fewer than 50 single-family homes, plus the Sunset Key Cottages resort, on about 27 acres.

Key West

Historic charm, walkability, dining, and a more energetic island lifestyle.

Explore nearby Florida Keys communities

EXPLORE MORE AREAS

For buyers looking for a quieter pace, more space, and laid-back island living, Cudjoe Key and the Lower Keys offer a very different feel from the Upper and Middle Keys.

Cudjoe Key

Islamorada

Known for its refined waterfront lifestyle, boating culture, and strong second-home appeal in the Upper and Middle Keys.

Contact Us

Whether you're buying a private island home or selling on Sunset Key, Greg Gordon works with you directly and discreetly, from the first private tour to closing day.

Buying or selling on Sunset Key?

Homes for sale in Sunset Key Florida Keys