Historic home in Key West Florida Keys

Old Town is the historic heart of Key West: tin-roofed conch houses, wide porches, shady lanes and some of the most recognizable streets in Florida. It sits inside the largest predominantly wooden historic district in the United States, with Duval Street, Mallory Square and the harbor all within a short walk.

The Island Collective Realty is based in Key West and broker-led. Greg Gordon works directly with every buyer, including the many buying a second home from out of state.

Browse Old Town Homes

Old Town Key West Real Estate

KEY WEST NEIGHBORHOOD GUIDE

Old Town is where Key West's history lives. Many homes date to the 1800s and early 1900s, and some are on the National Register of Historic Places. If you've pictured a Key West home with a front porch and a white picket fence, it's probably in Old Town.

It's also the most convenient place on the island to live without a car. Restaurants, galleries, the farmers market and the waterfront are all a short walk or bike ride away, which is a big reason Old Town is the most sought-after part of Key West.

Why buyers choose Old Town

AREA OVERVIEW

Waterfront home in Key West Florida Keys

What people love about Old Town

THE LIFESTYLE

Galleries, live music, festivals and some of the best restaurants in Florida, right outside your door.

Island culture

Conch cottages, eyebrow houses and grand Victorians, many lovingly restored with modern kitchens and pocket pools.

Historic home

Walk or bike everywhere

Dinner on Duval, sunset at Mallory Square and coffee in the morning, all without starting the car.

Residential street view in Key West Florida Keys

Old Town has the widest range of homes in Key West, from small conch cottages and condos to large historic estates. Most homes are wood-frame, many have private gardens and pocket pools, and off-street parking is a rare and valuable extra.

Because Old Town is a historic district, exterior changes and renovations go through the city's historic architecture review. We walk every buyer through what that means before they make an offer, so there are no surprises after closing.

View Old Town Listings

Old Town homes and prices

HOMES AND PRICES

A protected district

Historic preservation rules keep Old Town looking like Old Town, which helps protect the character you're buying into.

What makes Old Town unique

THE AREA

Old Town is consistently the busiest part of the Key West market, with buyers from all over the country.

Strong demand

Waterfront nearby

The harbor, the Historic Seaport and Fort Zachary Taylor's beach are all within walking or biking distance.

A typical day in Old Town might start with a bike ride for Cuban coffee, include a swim at Fort Zachary Taylor and end with dinner a few blocks from home. Grocery stores, the hospital and the airport are all a short drive away.

Old Town is lively, especially near Duval Street. Buyers who want more quiet often look a few blocks off the main streets, or at nearby neighborhoods like The Meadows and Casa Marina. We'll help you find the right block, not just the right house.

Life in Old Town

LIVING HERE

Waterfront home in Key West Florida Keys

IS OLD TOWN A GOOD PLACE TO BUY A SECOND HOME?

Yes, for many buyers it's the first choice. You can arrive, park the car and walk everywhere. Many owners use their home part of the year and rent it monthly or seasonally the rest of the year, where the rules allow.

Old Town real estate FAQs

FAQS

WHAT DO HOMES COST IN OLD TOWN?

Prices range widely, from condos and small cottages to multi-million-dollar historic estates. Text or call Greg for current numbers from the MLS, matched to your budget and wish list.

CAN I RENT OUT MY OLD TOWN HOME AS A VACATION RENTAL?

It depends on the property. Most Key West homes can only be rented for 30 days or more unless they hold a transient rental license. Ask us before you buy, and we'll check the specific home.

ARE THERE RULES FOR RENOVATING AN OLD TOWN HOME?

Yes. Old Town is a historic district, so exterior changes go through historic architecture review. Interior updates are usually simpler. We'll tell you what to expect for any home you're considering.

Truman Annex

A gated, landscaped community inside Old Town, built on the former naval station near the Little White House.

Explore nearby Key West neighborhoods

EXPLORE MORE AREAS

Larger homes on tree-lined streets near Higgs Beach and the island's south shore.

Casa Marina

The Meadows

A quiet, all-residential pocket of historic homes just east of Old Town's busiest streets.

Contact Us

Whether you're buying a historic Old Town home, a condo or a second home from out of state, Greg Gordon works with you directly, from the first video walk-through to closing day.

Buying or selling in Old Town?

Homes for sale in Key West Florida Keys