🌊 Welcome to Key Colony Beach Real Estate
Key Colony Beach, located just east of Marathon, is a charming island city in the Middle Florida Keys known for its waterfront living, community atmosphere, and walkability. With canals throughout the island and direct access to the Atlantic Ocean and Gulf of Mexico, it’s one of the most popular destinations for boating and fishing enthusiasts. At The Little Island Group, we specialize in helping buyers and sellers take advantage of everything this unique market has to offer.
🏝 Key Colony Beach Real Estate – Homes for Sale in the Florida Keys
🏡 Why Buy a Home in Key Colony Beach?
Key Colony Beach is one of the most desirable neighborhoods in the Middle Keys. Buyers love it for:
Extensive canal-front homes with private docks.
Vacation rental potential — the city allows weekly rentals, making it popular with investors.
Walkable lifestyle — restaurants, shops, and the beach are all nearby.
Proximity to Marathon for schools, medical care, and daily conveniences.
Additional insight: Unlike many Keys communities, Key Colony Beach is a self-contained city, offering its own police, city services, and community programs, which adds to the appeal for homeowners seeking security and structure.
📍 Key Colony Beach Neighborhoods & Communities
The majority of Key Colony Beach homes sit along canals, offering easy access to the ocean or bay. Many feature docks, pools, and rental licenses.
Along the oceanfront, buyers will find a mix of condos, townhomes, and single-family estates with sweeping views of the Atlantic.
Canal Homes
Oceanfront Homes & Condos
🌴 The Key Colony Beach Lifestyle
Life in Key Colony Beach balances relaxation with activity:
Boating & Fishing 🎣: Quick access to the Gulf and Atlantic.
Walkability 🚶: A rare feature in the Keys — most of the island is walkable, with dining and shops nearby.
Beaches 🏝: Residents and visitors enjoy nearby Cabana Club and Sunset Park Beach.
Community Feel 🏘: With its own city government and events, the island maintains a close-knit, small-town vibe.
📊 Key Colony Beach Real Estate Market Insights
The Key Colony Beach market is extremely competitive due to its size and demand:
Median Price Range: Many homes fall between $900K–$2M, with luxury waterfront estates exceeding that.
Vacation Rentals: One of the few Keys communities with weekly rentals allowed by city code, making it especially attractive for investors.
Property Types: Canal-front homes, ocean-view condos, townhomes, and duplexes for income potential.
Buyer Considerations: Short-term rental rules, flood zones, and insurance are important to review before purchase.
See current listings: Key Colony Beach Homes for Sale
🙋 Work with The Island Collective Realty
Buying or selling in Key Colony Beach requires local knowledge. Our team understands everything from flood zones and insurance requirements to investment potential and rental regulations. Whether you’re relocating full-time, searching for a vacation property, or selling your home, we’ll guide you every step of the way.
📞 Contact Us- today to start your Key Colony Beach real estate journey.
❓ FAQs About Key Colony Beach Real Estate
Yes. Unlike many Florida Keys communities, Key Colony Beach allows weekly rentals, making it a top choice for investors.
Key Colony Beach is directly connected to Marathon via a short causeway, giving residents easy access to the airport, shopping, schools, and restaurants.
Yes. Nearly every property sits on a canal or oceanfront, making it one of the most water-accessible cities in the Keys.
Key Colony Beach is one of the only self-governing cities in the Keys, with its own services, events, and community programs. It’s also more walkable than most islands.
Does Key Colony Beach allow vacation rentals?
How close is Key Colony Beach to Marathon?
Are most homes in Key Colony Beach waterfront?
What makes Key Colony Beach unique compared to other Keys communities?
You're in the right place.
It's no mystery that we are in our own little island bubble down here in the Florida Keys. From island time to island life, we do things a bit differently. But, if you get it you get it and when you're ready we're here to help. Whether buying your own piece of paradise, selling some Keys real estate, restoring a historic property, or renting out your home as a vacation rental, we'd love to chat with you. Ready to make some real estate moves down here in the islands?
Owning a piece of the Florida Keys means owning a slice of paradise. The process of buying, selling, renovating, and renting on the island can come with challenges so we are here to help.
"What made me happiest is that Stephanie was ON it. I thought I was diligent about combing through listings. But, she was always a step ahead of me. In the past, we've attempted to make progress in moving to the island. But we were not able to get the traction that we needed to strike while the iron was hot. Without Stephanie, I would still be shivering up north."
is always of the essence
Time
"Stephanie and Greg treated us like we were not just clients, but old friends. They answered panicked emails and texts with a sweet sense of humor."
the secret sauce
levity
real results
Buying your perfect piece of paradise is such an exciting time. We are here to help make the process as fruitful, fun, and easy as possible.
Buying
Renting your property can be challenging. Our team is here to do the heavy lifting so you can enjoy the cash and skip the headaches.
VACATION RENTAL MANAGEMENT
When it's time to embark on your next adventure, we're here to help get your house sold. Our consultative process keeps you feeling supported from start to finish!
Selling
Ways to Work Together
“Key West? That's not a place it's a dream.”
— anonymous
Buying in the Florida Keys
From waterfront estates in Islamorada to historic Old Town Key West cottages, we guide buyers through every step of the process. Our team offers local insight, market strategy, and personalized tours to help you discover not just a property, but your perfect island home.
Owning a piece of the Florida Keys is a dream you're ready to realize. Say no more!
A GOOD FIT FOR YOU IF:
You're ready to own a little slice of paradise but you're a little overwhelmed and not sure where to start. The islands are calling but you aren't quite sure how to answer!
You want the vacation rental revenues but not the vacation rental headaches. Oh! And proactive, customized marketing for your property would be swell.
A GOOD FIT FOR YOU IF:
Yes, we take care of your property like it is our own. Yes, we represent it on the usual online rental platforms. Here's our real difference: Our social media reach is millions. We have a large devoted following who look to us for recommendations on where to stay on the island. We actively and innovatively promote your property to increase occupancy and thus revenue.
Rental Management in Key West
Your vacation rental can be a blessing and a headache. Keep the cash leave the headaches to us.
We're about as low-pressure as they come, but we'd love to chat when you're ready.
Ready to Talk About Working Together?
lets do this.