Historic home in Key West Florida Keys

Casa Marina is Key West's beach neighborhood: quiet, tree-lined streets on the island's south shore, a few blocks from Higgs Beach and the White Street Pier. It takes its name from the historic Casa Marina hotel, built in the era of Henry Flagler's railroad.

The Island Collective Realty is based in Key West and broker-led. Greg Gordon works directly with every buyer, including the many buying a second home from out of state.

Browse Casa Marina Homes

Casa Marina Real Estate

KEY WEST NEIGHBORHOOD GUIDE

Casa Marina was Key West's first "suburb." Well-known Old Town families moved to this side of the island for a little more elbow room, and that is still the draw today: bigger homes, bigger lots and a calmer feel.

You get the best of both worlds. The beach and the ocean are a short walk away, and Duval Street is an easy bike ride. For buyers who want water access and quiet, Casa Marina is often at the top of the list.

Why buyers choose Casa Marina

AREA OVERVIEW

Waterfront home in Key West Florida Keys

What people love about Casa Marina

THE LIFESTYLE

Shady, mostly residential blocks that are perfect for walking the dog or an evening bike ride.

Quiet streets

Larger homes, wider lots and more off-street parking than most of Old Town.

Room to breathe

Steps to the beach

Higgs Beach, the White Street Pier and the waterfront parks are part of your daily routine here.

Residential street view in Key West Florida Keys

Casa Marina has a mix of classic Key West homes, mid-century houses, renovated estates and a handful of condos. Homes here tend to be larger than in the rest of Old Town, and many have pools, gardens and ocean breezes.

It is consistently one of the highest-priced neighborhoods in Key West, because of its size, its location and how close it is to the ocean. Text or call Greg for current numbers from the MLS.

View Casa Marina Listings

Casa Marina homes and prices

HOMES AND PRICES

The south shore

Some of the island's best waterfront recreation: swimming, snorkeling, tennis, pickleball and sunrise walks on the pier.

What makes Casa Marina unique

THE AREA

Many owners live here year-round or for the whole season, which gives the area a real neighborhood feel.

Long-term neighbors

A storied history

Named for the historic Casa Marina hotel, a Key West landmark since the Flagler railroad era.

A typical day might start with a swim at Higgs Beach, include lunch at a beachside restaurant and end with a bike ride to Old Town for dinner. Grocery stores and everyday errands are a few minutes away.

Casa Marina is quieter than the streets around Duval, but you're never far from the action. It's a favorite for full-time residents, families and second-home owners who want the beach close by.

Life in Casa Marina

LIVING HERE

Waterfront home in Key West Florida Keys

IS CASA MARINA A GOOD PLACE TO BUY A SECOND HOME?

Yes. It's one of the most popular choices for second-home buyers who want the beach close by and a quieter street, while still being a short ride from Old Town.

Casa Marina real estate FAQs

FAQS

WHAT DO HOMES COST IN CASA MARINA?

Casa Marina is one of Key West's higher-priced neighborhoods, with everything from condos to multi-million-dollar estates. Text or call Greg for current numbers matched to your budget.

CAN I RENT OUT MY CASA MARINA HOME AS A VACATION RENTAL?

It depends on the property. Most Key West homes can only be rented for 30 days or more unless they hold a transient rental license. Ask us before you buy, and we'll check the specific home.

HOW IS CASA MARINA DIFFERENT FROM OLD TOWN?

Casa Marina is quieter and closer to the beach, with larger homes and lots. Old Town is more walkable to Duval Street and has more of the classic historic cottages.

Truman Annex

A gated, landscaped community inside Old Town, built on the former naval station near the Little White House.

Explore nearby Key West neighborhoods

EXPLORE MORE AREAS

Mid-century homes, more space and easy access to Smathers Beach and the White Street galleries.

Midtown

The Meadows

A quiet, all-residential pocket of historic homes just east of Old Town's busiest streets.

Contact Us

Whether you're buying a beach-side home, a condo or a second home from out of state, Greg Gordon works with you directly, from the first video walk-through to closing day.

Buying or selling in Casa Marina?

Homes for sale in Key West Florida Keys